Chapter 1
Brett and I had an unspoken tradition: every Halloween belonged to us.
Then came his corporate transfer to Chicago. Three years passed, and three Octobers vanished into thin air. By the end, getting him on a simple FaceTime call felt like petitioning a stranger.
This year, I refused to let the distance hollow us out. Weeks in advance, I booked a flight to see him. But the day of my departure, an autumn gale swept the coast, grounding every plane on the tarmac.
Desperate, I signed for a rental sedan and drove eleven straight hours through the lashing rain and sleet.
By the time I pulled into the city, dusk was already falling over the brownstones. It was Halloween night. I sat in the idling car, adjusting the white rabbit mask I’d brought—an homage to the rabbit cop from that animated film we used to rewatch until the dialogue became our private shorthand.
I walked up to his apartment building, clutching a tin of artisan chocolates, my heart fluttering with nervous anticipation.
Then the front doors swung open.
Brett walked out, side-by-side with a young woman.
She, too, wore a rabbit mask—velvet ears tipped in silver, a fluffy tail pinned to her flared skirt. Her arm was tucked securely into Brett’s elbow, her head tilted toward his shoulder.
"Thank you for spending our third Halloween together," she said, her voice light and musical against the chill.
Brett turned to look down at her. His gaze held a soft, lingering warmth I hadn't seen directed at me in years.
"The pleasure is all mine, little bunny."
Standing on the sidewalk, my fingers tightened around the metal edges of the tin, cold and unyielding against my skin.
Every deadline. Every missed anniversary. Every hollow excuse of being buried under quarterly reviews. All of it had simply been reserved for someone else's Halloween.
I didn't storm up the steps. I didn't scream or make a scene. I simply turned around, walked back to the rental car, and turned the key in the ignition.
Three years is an eternity—long enough for two people to drift into parallel universes.
And yet, three years is nothing at all, because watching the person you love become a ghost takes only a single, quiet breath.
1
"Maren, we’re buried under this massive enterprise rollout tonight. I really can’t get away."
I had barely driven a mile from his neighborhood when Brett’s text lit up the dashboard.
The pale blue glow illuminated the rabbit mask sitting on the passenger seat, alongside the tin of chocolates I had guarded with my life across three states.
I pulled over against the curb, letting the hazard lights click in the quiet car, staring at the message.
In years past, an excuse like this would have come with receipts: a candid snapshot of a chaotic desk, half-empty paper coffee cups, a blurry spreadsheet. Proof of his martyrdom. Tonight, there wasn't even a photo. He was likely too captivated by his companion to bother staging a defense.
I typed back with numb fingers: "It’s fine. Focus on your work."
The reply was instantaneous.
"I’m so sorry, babe. Once this wave settles, I promise I’ll take a long weekend and come home to you."
"Be good. Get some sleep."
That word—"be good"—settled in my stomach like a spoonful of lead.
Five years together. Three years separated by miles. And now, he lied with the practiced, casual elegance of someone breathing.
I didn't answer. I flipped the phone face down onto the console. Eleven hours behind the wheel had hollowed me out completely.
I checked into a plain chain hotel three blocks from his firm’s high-rise office downtown. In the harsh fluorescent light of the bathroom mirror, the woman looking back at me was a stranger: gaunt, paper-pale, dark shadows bruising the skin under her bloodshot eyes. I had cashed in every hour of paid leave I owned, grinding until two in the morning for two straight weeks just to clear this window.
All for a surprise that had curdled into a solitary nightmare.
The next morning, holding a lukewarm paper cup of coffee from the lobby, I took the elevator up to his office floor.
He didn't know I was there. I simply wanted to bear witness to the massive, inescapable project that had kept him bound to his desk.
The receptionist was unfamiliar, young and polished, eyeing my wrinkled trench coat with mild suspicion.
"Can I help you? Do you have an appointment?"
"I’m looking for Brett," I said.
Her expression shifted, tightening into something faintly condescending. "Mr. Morrison? And you are?"
"His girlfriend."
A sharp, involuntary snicker escaped her lips before she could catch herself. The patronizing pity in her eyes was unmistakable.
"Ma'am, Mr. Morrison’s girlfriend is already upstairs in the executive suite," she said, shaking her head. "If you're looking for an intro, you might want to try a more original pitch."
The air left my lungs. My fingers crushed the paper cup in my grip, tepid coffee pooling around the rim.
Here, in this glass tower, everybody knew he had a partner. It just wasn't me.
Before I could speak, the elevator chimed behind me.
Brett stepped out, impeccably tailored in a charcoal wool suit, walking with the easy stride of a rising star.
Beside him walked the girl from the night before.
Without the mask, her features were delicate, fresh, and disarmingly young. Her name was Carly. I remembered her from the fringes of company group photos on Brett's social feed—the ones he had dismissed with a wave of his hand when I asked: "Just a fresh hire, clumsy, still learning the ropes."
Now, that clumsy intern was wrapped in Brett’s oversized black trench coat. The heavy fabric swamped her petite frame in a way that screamed intimacy. In her hands, she cupped an artisanal oat latte, smiling up at him as she spoke. Brett was bent low, catching her words with an indulgent, familiar grin.
Then the receptionist called out. "Mr. Morrison! This woman claims she's your girlfriend and insisted on seeing you."
Brett froze mid-step.
His head snapped up. His eyes drifted across the lobby and collided with mine.
The smile on his face didn't fade—it shattered, his pupils dilating in sheer shock. The leather portfolio in his left hand slipped, nearly tumbling to the polished marble floor.
"Maren?"
His voice was hoarse, as if his throat were coated in dry sand.
Carly followed his gaze. When she realized who I was, a fleeting flash of guilt flickered across her eyes, smoothed over almost instantly by a practiced, sugary pout.
"Brett?" she asked, leaning subtly into his side. "Who is she?"
Brett. Not Mr. Morrison.
He covered the distance between us in hurried strides, unable to meet my level stare.
"What are you doing here?"
"Did you finish your big project?" I asked evenly.
The color drained from his jaw. He subtly shifted his stance, positioning himself slightly ahead of Carly, shielding her from my line of sight.
"Pulled an all-nighter. Wrapped it up an hour ago," he muttered, reaching out toward the crushed coffee cup in my hand. "It's freezing down here. Let’s head up to my office."
I pulled my arm back, letting his hand drop into empty air.
Carly stepped forward, clasping her hands behind her back. The hem of Brett’s coat swayed around her calves.
"You must be Maren," she said sweetly. "Brett talks about you all the time. He mentioned yesterday that you were trying to come down—we even had a little department welcome ready for you!"
I looked past her, fixing my eyes squarely on Brett. "Yesterday?"
Brett’s composure cracked entirely. A beaded line of sweat appeared at his hairline. He shot Carly a sharp, warning glance, but she seemed blithely oblivious—or calculatedly deaf.
"Yeah," Carly chirped. "Brett told us Halloween is your favorite holiday. Our team stayed late carving pumpkins and stringing up fairy lights. It was such a bummer when your flight got canceled."
I took a slow breath. "You told them I was coming?"
Brett swallowed hard. "Maren, let me explain. When the flights shut down, I assumed you were stuck back home. I didn’t want to rub it in that we were having an office mixer while you were alone in the apartment."
He dressed up his betrayal as kindness.
I didn't bother to argue. Instead, my gaze dropped to the coat swaddling Carly's shoulders. "That coat looks familiar."
Brett jumped in instantly. "The AC in the conference room was blasting. Carly caught a chill, so I lent it to her."
Carly pulled the lapels tighter around her throat, looking at me with wide, innocent eyes. "You don't mind, do you, Maren? My immune system is terrible in the fall. Brett’s always taking care of me like this."
The territory marking was so transparent it felt insulting.
"Keep it," I said, tossing my crushed cup into the stainless steel bin beside the pillar. "It’s just an old jacket."
After all, she had already borrowed the man wearing it for three years.
Brett exhaled, visibly relieved, and reached out to grasp my wrist. "Come on. Let me take you out for an early lunch."
His skin was fever-warm, but when his fingers closed around mine, a wave of nausea washed over me.
2
He took me to an upscale bistro three blocks away.
Carly wasn't invited; it was just the two of us seated at a private corner booth flooded with soft autumn light.
Brett was attentive to a fault. He wiped down the silverware with a clean cloth napkin, pushed the bread basket toward me, and ordered a cup of warm roasted pumpkin bisque.
"You’ve got a sensitive stomach," he said, his voice wrapped in gentle solicitude, as if he could bridge three years of absence with warm soup. "They make it smooth here. Easy on your digestion."
I watched his hands move. When did Brett learn to anticipate someone else's comfort? Back home, he used to complain if I asked him to fetch a pitcher of water from the fridge.
"You come here often?" I asked casually.
His hands hesitated over the water carafe. "Now and then. For business lunches."
A young waiter arrived with our plates, flashing a practiced, familiar smile. "Good to see you again, Mr. Morrison! The usual setup today? No shallots, extra grilled shrimp on the side? And is Miss Carly joining you later?"
The air in the booth solidified.
Brett’s jaw locked. He cut the waiter off with a curt, icy edge: "No. Just the items from the lunch menu today, thanks."
Sensing the sudden drop in temperature, the waiter stammered an apology and retreated.
I took a sip of lukewarm water. "Miss Carly is Carly, I assume?"
Brett stared at the white tablecloth.
"You're allergic to shellfish," I added softly. "Who was the extra shrimp for?"
Brett pressed the heels of his palms into his eyes, letting out a heavy, irritated sigh. "Maren, don't read into this. She’s fresh out of college. She moved out here with zero family and zero support. I'm her direct lead—mentoring her and looking out for her is just part of my job."
I nodded slowly. "Of course. Part of your job."
"Mentoring her into matching bunny costumes? Mentoring her into wearing your coat so she can mark her territory in front of me?"
His face hardened, irritation breaking through his guilty veneer. "Do you have to make everything sound so vulgar? Carly isn't like that. She’s naive, completely transparent. She doesn't have an ounce of malice in her."
I almost laughed out loud.
So in his eyes, she was pure and guileless, while I was bitter, calculating, and cynical.
I barely touched the food.
When the bill arrived, Brett’s phone buzzed on the mahogany table. The screen flashed with the name "Greg".
Greg had been Brett’s college roommate, and was now his business partner in the Chicago branch.
Brett answered, and Greg’s boisterous, unfiltered voice leaked clearly through the speaker.
"Hey, Brett! Did you make Carly cry? She's in the breakroom with her eyes swollen, whining that she pissed off your real girlfriend."
Brett’s eyes flicked up to mine. He lowered his voice to a hurried rasp. "Drop it, Greg. Not now."
Greg groaned on the other end. "Look, Maren’s pushing thirty, shouldn't she know how the world works by now? You’ve been grinding your teeth out in this city for three years. Carly stepped up and kept your life together—Maren should be buying the kid flowers, not rolling in like the queen bee giving people hell."
I sat across from him, entirely still.
Three years ago, on the eve of his departure, Brett had held me in our small living room, crying into my neck. He had sworn that three years was nothing—that he would build a life for us and come back to put a ring on my finger. He told me to take care of myself, because who else would pick the bones out of my salmon?
It turned out someone else had taken over that chore.
Someone else was keeping his life together.
Brett slammed his thumb onto the red button, cutting the line. "Greg’s an idiot who talks before he thinks. Don't pay attention to him."
I slid out of the booth and stood up. "I'm going back to the hotel to sleep."
He caught my sleeve. "I don't have anything on my calendar this afternoon. Let me walk around the city with you."
I thought of his phantom enterprise project. "No need. Go back and dry your intern's tears."
His eyebrows pulled together, his tone turning brittle. "Maren, could you stop being so unreasonable for once? I told you she's just a colleague. What more do you want from me?"
I looked down at him, seeing the stranger behind the familiar face. "I don't want anything from you."
I pulled my arm free and walked out into the crisp autumn wind alone.
I slept heavily through the afternoon, exhausted down to the marrow. When I finally woke, twilight had turned the hotel room a bruised, dusty blue.
There was a text waiting from Brett:
"Greg’s hosting a dinner tonight at a private lounge with a few of the guys. Consider it a proper welcome for you. Come through."
My first impulse was to delete it. But after a moment, I typed back: "Okay."
I wanted to see how far they were willing to take the farce.
When I pushed open the frosted glass doors of the private dining room that evening, the laughter inside cut off abruptly.
Greg sat at the head of the table, Brett beside him. And seated on Brett’s right was Carly.
She had traded the black trench coat for an ivory cashmere sweater, soft and demure, projecting the image of a delicate, obedient angel.
The room held its breath.
Brett stood up quickly, pulling out the empty chair between himself and Greg. "Maren. Sit here."
I walked over and sat down.
Before I could unfold my napkin, Carly poured a cup of herbal tea and pushed it across the glass turntable toward me. "Drink some, Maren. It’ll warm you up."
As she reached out, the cuff of her sleeve fell back, revealing a delicate sterling silver chain bracelet on her wrist. Hanging from the links was a tiny, engraved star.
My chest seized. My breath caught in my throat.
Two years ago, for Brett’s birthday, I had scrimped on groceries for three months to buy us matching sterling star bracelets. One for him, one for me. Last spring, he claimed he had lost his at a gym locker room, and I had spent an entire weekend mourning the loss.
Yet there it was. Polished, gleaming, and locked around Carly’s wrist.
I raised my eyes to Brett.
He followed my gaze, and every drop of color drained from his face.
3
Brett’s hand shot out, grabbing Carly’s wrist with frantic urgency. "Why are you wearing that?"
His voice was a hushed, strangled hiss, trembling with undisguised panic.
Carly flinched, pulling her shoulder inward, her eyes instantly welling with glossy tears. "Brett... you're hurting me."
She looked up at him, her lower lip quivering. "Didn't you throw this in your car console months ago and say you didn't want it anymore? I thought it looked pretty, so I put it on. Is it... is it really that valuable?"
Greg chimed in from the head of the table, waving a dismissive hand. "Come on, Brett, it's just a piece of silver. Why are you snapping at the kid?" He glanced at me, flashing a hollow, placating grin. "Maren, she didn't know it was a gift. Honest mistake. You're the bigger person here—don't hold it against a girl who doesn't know any better."
I looked at Greg’s smug, patronizing face, feeling a surreal detachment wash over me.
A token of five years of devotion.
Discarded in a cup holder. Labeled trash. Gifted to another woman.
And if I dared to feel the sting of it, I was simply petty, lacking grace, picking on a child.
I didn't utter a word. I just kept my eyes locked on Brett.
Brett couldn't bear to look back at me. With clumsy, aggressive movements, he unclasped the bracelet from Carly’s wrist and shoved it deep into his trousers pocket.
"I'll buy you a new one tomorrow," he muttered to Carly under his breath.
A soft, teary smile bloomed on Carly's face. "Thanks, Brett."
The rest of the dinner was agonizingly stifling.
When a platter of garlic-crusted king crab was set on the table, Carly immediately cracked open a fat claw, carefully extracted the sweet white meat, and dropped it onto Brett’s small plate.
"Eat this, Brett. You've been craving it all week."
Brett loved seafood, but he loathed the effort of cracking shells. For five years, I had been the one peeling his shrimp, deshelling his crab, nursing his lazy appetite.
Now, he picked up his fork and swallowed the meat naturally. "Thanks."
Greg chuckled loudly. "See that? Carly knows how to spoil a guy. Brett, your stomach’s gone completely soft because of her."
Brett’s fork paused for a fraction of a second, but he didn't correct him.
They drifted into inside jokes about the office, mocking difficult corporate clients, debating tee times for Sunday golf. I sat among them like an uninvited ghost, an artifact from a past life that none of them had the decency to acknowledge.
Midway through the meal, Carly knocked over her water goblet, splashing ice water across the skirt of her dress.
Brett was on his feet instantly. He yanked a handful of linen napkins from the dispenser, crouching beside her chair to dab at her hem. "How did you manage that? Are you burned? Is it cold?"
His voice practically vibrated with anxiety.
Carly shook her head, blushing prettily. "I'm okay, just made a mess of my dress. I'll go clean up in the ladies' room."
"I'll walk you down the hall," Brett said without hesitation.
They stepped out together, one after the other.
Greg took a slow drag from his drink and turned to me. "Maren, to be fair, Brett hasn't had it easy these past three years. Building an outpost from scratch is brutal."
I turned the porcelain teacup between my thumb and forefinger. "And you think I'm overreacting?"
Greg sighed, leaning back. "Honestly? Long-distance kills passion. Men need someone present, someone who keeps the hearth warm. If you couldn't be here for him, you can't really hold the reins this tight."
I looked down at the pale amber tea and smiled faintly.
"I" couldn't be here for him?
He was the one who volunteered for the three-year tour to secure a partner track.
I was the one who stayed behind, driving three hours every weekend to sit in hospital waiting rooms with his ailing mother so he wouldn't have to fly back. I was the one who lived on canned soup and store-brand groceries so I could wire him an extra thousand dollars a month during his lean first year, terrified he would skip meals in the city.
And now, the narrative had flipped. I had failed to provide warmth, so I deserved to be quietly replaced.
The heavy door creaked open. Brett and Carly returned, side-by-side. Her skirt was damp, but her cheeks glowed with a delicate, satisfied pink.
By the time the bill was settled, the sky outside had ruptured into a violent autumn deluge.
Thunder rattled the plate-glass windows of the lobby as sheets of water pounded the pavement. We stood beneath the wide awning, waiting for the valet.
Carly shivered, drawing closer to Brett’s shoulder. "The thunder is so loud... I've always hated storms."
Brett’s arm naturally came up around her shoulders, tucking her against his chest. "You're fine. I'm right here."
He turned his head toward me, his expression caught somewhere between exhaustion and impatience. "Maren, the weather’s terrible, and cabs are going to be impossible to hail. Carly’s place is only a few blocks away, and she gets panic attacks in thunderstorms. I’m going to run her home in the SUV first. Can you just call an Uber from the lobby?"
I stood under the concrete eaves in my thin trench coat. The wind whipped rain against my bare ankles, sending a deep, hollow chill through my ribs.
"Brett," I said, my voice barely carrying over the downpour. "My hotel is three traffic lights down the boulevard."
His brow furrowed into an irritated knot. "Maren, please don't start acting like a child right now. She’s terrified. You're a grown woman—you can wait twenty minutes for a ride."
Greg chimed in from the curb, keys jangling. "Seriously, Maren. He’ll drop her and loop right back. Why pick a fight over logistics?"
I stared at Brett’s arm, draped possessively over the girl’s shivering shoulders.
"Fine," I said softly. "Go drive her home."
Brett let out a breath of relief. Without leaving me an umbrella, without waiting to see if my ride would ever arrive, he sheltered Carly beneath his jacket and dashed into the pouring rain.
The black SUV pulled away, its taillights bleeding red streaks across the wet asphalt before vanishing into the storm.
I stood under the awning for an hour.
The rain soaked through the cuffs of my trousers, and the cold settled deep into my bones, freezing out whatever was left of my heart.
4
The ring of my phone dragged me out of an uneasy sleep the next morning.
A low-grade fever had set in; my temples throbbed with a dull, heavy ache.
"Maren? Did you catch a cold waiting for that cab last night? Did you take anything?"
Brett’s voice came through the receiver, heavy with performative guilt.
I stared at the ceiling tiles of the hotel room. "I'm not dead."
He choked on his words, softening his tone into something coaxing. "Don't be angry, okay? Last night was a mess. It's Saturday—let me take you to the movies to make it up to you. That indie film you've been talking about forever."
I closed my eyes. My flight home was booked for tomorrow afternoon. This would likely be the last afternoon we would ever spend in the same room.
"Three o'clock," I said. "I'll meet you at your apartment."
At two-thirty, I stood outside his front door.
The keypad lock still answered to my birthday. The latch clicked, and the door swung inward.
The apartment was cluttered. A couple of coats he rarely wore were draped over the sofa back. Feeling feverish, I walked toward the bathroom to splash cold water on my face.
On the marble vanity, two sonic toothbrushes stood side by side in a single ceramic holder.
One navy blue. One blush pink.
On the chrome rail beside the mirror hung two matching towels—one slate, one rose.
The domesticity of it was suffocating. Every corner of the flat bore the subtle, settled footprint of another woman’s daily life.
I leaned against the doorframe, my chest tightening until drawing air felt like inhaling broken glass. He hadn't just given away his affection over these three years; he had given away his home.
I didn't touch anything. I stepped back into the living room and walked over to the floor-to-ceiling windows.
Brett emerged from the bedroom, buttoning his collar. "Maren? When did you get in? Why didn't you say anything?"
His gaze caught mine, tracking my line of sight back toward the bathroom. His expression fractured. He took two swift steps across the rug and pulled the bathroom door shut with a muffled click.
"Those... those belong to Greg’s girl," he explained rapidly, the words tumbling out too fast. "She crashed here for a weekend when their pipes burst. I keep forgetting to toss them."
I met his frantic eyes. "You don't even bother rehearsing your lies anymore, do you?"
He stepped forward, reaching out to pull me into an embrace. "Let’s not do this today, Maren. Let’s just go to the theater."
Before his hands could touch my shoulders, his phone on the credenza began to chime.
The screen lit up with the caller ID: "Carly".
His reflex was to silence it, but his thumb hovered over the screen for a full, paralyzed second.
That hesitation was all the answer I needed.
He took the call.
Through the receiver, Carly’s voice came through in sharp, breathless sobs.
"Brett... where are you? I went down to the mailroom and slipped on the stairs... my ankle is swollen like a balloon. It hurts so bad... can you come help me?"
Brett’s face instantly twisted in distress. "Is it bad? Can you put any weight on it?"
"I can't stand... Brett, please..."
Brett ended the call and turned back to me, his eyes full of pleading desperation. "Maren, she took a bad fall. She lives alone, she has nobody in the city. I need to take her to urgent care. If it's a hairline fracture, it could get complicated."
I looked at him quietly. "We had plans."
He grabbed my wrists, squeezing tight. "We’ll go tomorrow, okay? I’ll give you the entire day tomorrow. But she’s a kid, Maren—if she’s hurt, I can't just leave her stranded."
Slowly, deliberately, I slid my hands out of his grip.
"I'm leaving tomorrow, Brett."
He paused, caught off guard. "Leaving? Where?"
"Home. My leave is over."
He exhaled, visibly relaxing, and reached up to casually brush a strand of hair from my forehead. "That’s probably for the best. The weather here is miserable anyway, not good for you. Wait for me—I’ll drive you to O'Hare tomorrow morning. I’m really sorry about today, but I have to go."
He snatched his keys from the bowl by the door and left without looking back.
The heavy deadbolt clicked into place. The apartment sank into a dead, suffocating silence.
I stood there in the quiet room, my eyes dry. I had no tears left to spend.
I walked into his bedroom. From his dresser, I pulled out every silk tie, every cufflink, every wristwatch I had gifted him over the last five years.
I swept them into a heavy black trash bag.
I walked to the kitchen, took the pair of monogrammed ceramic mugs we had bought together, and dropped them into the bin beneath the sink, listening to the porcelain shatter against the plastic liner.
I systematically erased every trace of my existence from his home.
Then I tied off the bag, walked out into the corridor, and left the building behind.
The afternoon wind was bitter.
I didn't return to the hotel. I flagged a cab straight to the airport. Sitting in the departure terminal, I pulled up the airline app and changed my flight to the six o'clock red-eye.
Ten minutes before boarding commenced, my phone buzzed in my lap.
Three messages from Brett:
"Her ankle is sprained. The doctor wants her off her feet for a few days."
"I probably can’t make it back to your hotel tonight. I have to stay to help her with prescriptions and check-in."
"I’ll be at your hotel first thing in the morning to take you to the airport. Be good and wait for me."
I stared at those texts, and the final trace of lingering regret dissolved into thin air.
I didn't reply.
I powered down the phone, slid the tray out, and snapped the plastic SIM card cleanly in two. I tossed the pieces into the wastebasket beside the gate.
Overhead, the chime sounded, announcing my boarding group.
I pulled up the handle of my carry-on and walked through the jet bridge without turning around.
There would be no tomorrow, Brett.
I was done waiting.