Chapter 1
My fiancé claimed he needed quiet.
On my birthdays, he wouldn’t let me blow out the candles; he said the sound of my breath broke his peace. Whenever I caught a cold, I had to swallow my coughs until my chest burned, just so the hacking wouldn’t grate on his nerves. At night, he made me sleep on the far edge of our king-sized bed, a chasm of sheets between us, insisting my tossing disrupted his sleep cycles.
Today was my birthday again.
The cake, the gifts, the dinner reservations—he had arranged everything to my supposed tastes. But this year, there was a third plate at the table.
Kelsey. His college sweetheart. The one who got away.
Shane smiled as he lit the twenty-six candles, and Kelsey belted out the birthday song, her voice loud, bright, and completely unbothered. She clapped her hands together, leaning across the mahogany table.
"Come on, Willa! Make a wish and blow them out!"
I leaned forward, inhaling.
Beside me, Shane’s brow furrowed into tight, familiar ridges. "Did you forget what I said?"
I froze, caught in the sudden cold draft of his disapproval. Before I could move, Kelsey let out a dramatic gasp.
"Oops, I got it!" She bent down and blew them all out in one sharp gust. "If I didn't, the wax would’ve ruined the frosting. You should be thanking me, Willa."
Her voice bounced off the quiet walls of the dining room, high and relentless.
A dull, familiar ache pooled under my ribs. I kept my mouth shut.
It turned out he didn't hate noise at all. He just hated mine.
Shane plucked the melted candles from the cake, his voice coated in an easy, indulgent tenderness I hadn't heard in years. "Good thing you caught it in time."
Then he turned to me, his tone instantly flattened. "Say thank you to Kelsey."
I looked at the two of them, and something inside me finally went slack, like a wire snapped clean through.
I didn't answer his demand. Instead, I said quietly, "I didn't forget what you told me."
"I'm doing what you asked. I won't make a sound in front of you ever again."
...
"Did you hear me?" Shane’s jaw tightened, impatience bleeding through his teeth. "I told you to thank her."
I looked at him calmly. This was my fiancé. The man who had once sworn to protect me, back when he was still trying to win me over.
He reached out, his fingers clamping hard around my jaw, forcibly twisting my face toward Kelsey. "What are you staring at me for? The person you need to thank is sitting right there. Is this how you treat a guest in our home?"
I tried to pull away, but he only tightened his grip. The pressure bruised into my cheekbones; a sharp gasp of pain escaped my throat before I could choke it back.
Only then did Kelsey step in, a soft, patronizing smile playing on her lips as she gently pulled his hand away. "Drop it, Shane. It was just a candle."
"Shane."
A nickname. An easy, affectionate syllable. I had never been allowed to call him that. Even on the night of our engagement dinner, when I had playfully whispered a pet name in his ear, he had pulled back in disgust. "Don't do that mushy crap. It’s repulsive."
Shane let his hand fall, scowling at me. "She never cared this much before. Now she's playing the mute martyr. Who is this performance for?"
"Was I playing a part?"
Before Shane, I was the girl who filled every room. I loved crowded diners, laughing until my stomach ached, talking about everything and nothing. When Shane first asked me out, I thought I was the luckiest woman in the world—that my feelings were finally being met.
Then he told me he needed quiet.
To love him, I shrank myself. I muted my laugh. I lowered my voice to a whisper. I learned to set coffee mugs down without a clink, to open drawers as if someone were sleeping in the next room, to breathe so shallowly I sometimes felt faint. Whenever I made the slightest sound, his forehead would bunch up in irritation.
"Don't be so crude. Keep it down."
I had believed relationships were about compromise. I convinced myself that learning to live softly was an act of devotion. I was willing to bend until I broke.
But looking at him now, I didn't want to bend anymore.
Seeing my blank face, Shane seemed to realize he had pushed too far. He softened his posture, picking up the silver knife to slice the cake. He slid the first piece onto a porcelain plate and pushed it toward me.
"Don't wear that funeral face on your birthday. Lighten up."
Kelsey’s eyes darted to the plate, her voice chirping with deliberate girlishness. "Shane! Look at that strawberry on top—it’s massive. You know those are my absolute favorite."
Shane’s hand hovered over the plate, pausing for a fraction of a second. Then, without a word to me, he pivoted, grabbed a dessert fork, and handed the plate to Kelsey.
"If you like it, take it."
He proceeded to pick off every single strawberry decorating the cake, piling them high on Kelsey’s plate. Then he cut another slice for me—nothing but plain, heavy sponge smothered in pale buttercream.
"Here," he said, sliding it over. "I know how much you love sweets."
I loved fruit tarts. I loved tart raspberries and fresh berries cut with a hint of lemon. I despised sickly-sweet, greasy buttercream.
Kelsey took a bite of her cake, then let out an exaggerated sigh. "Shane, we forgot to let her make a wish."
Shane glanced down at the butchered cake, looking faintly embarrassed for half a second. "Well, it’s already cut. Forget the wish. If there's something you want, Willa, just tell me. I’ll buy it for you."
I drew my hands back into my lap and said nothing.
His jaw set hard. The embarrassment twisted instantly into resentment. "Don't push it."
"Are you really this petty?" he scoffed. "Pouting because you didn't get to blow out a few sticks of wax? You won't talk, you won't eat, you won't make a wish."
The dining room was dead silent. Outside, an autumn wind rattled the windowpane. I didn't give him an inch.
Infuriated by the lack of an audience, Shane slammed both hands on his hips. With a sudden, vicious sweep of his arm, he shoved the remaining cake off the counter and straight into the trash can.
The box crumpled with a hollow thud.
"Fine. Don't eat it," he snarled. "You think having a birthday gives you the right to hold everyone hostage? I've spoiled you rotten."
I raised my chin and looked straight into his eyes.
"My wish," I said, my voice steady, "is to call off the wedding."
He blinked, stunned, before letting out a mocking laugh. "Cancel the wedding? The invitations went out two weeks ago, Willa. If you're going to throw a tantrum, at least pick an idle threat that sounds believable."
I offered him a tiny, bloodless smile.
If you don't intend to keep a promise, you shouldn't make it in the first place.
I reached up, unclipped the silly cardboard birthday crown from my hair, let it drop onto the hardwood floor, and walked into the bedroom.
Behind the closed door, the muffled crash of breaking glass echoed down the hall.
"Pouting all day long! Who does she think she is?!"
Then came Kelsey’s syrupy murmur. "She’s just stressed out lately, Shane. Cut her some slack. If only she could be a little more easygoing... like me."
"God, I wish," Shane muttered. "You actually know how to read a room."
I leaned my back against the heavy bedroom door, closing my eyes.
He was the one who demanded I be quiet. And he was the one who hated my silence.
I remembered a dinner party six months ago. Kelsey had been there. That night, Shane had uncharacteristically pulled me close, asking me questions, hanging on my every word in front of the crowd. I had been so intoxicated by his attention that I couldn't stop talking. On the drive home, riding high on the illusion of his affection, I had chattered excitedly about our upcoming plans.
He had pinched the bridge of his nose, his voice dropping into pure ice. "Shut up. You're giving me a migraine."
It made sense now.
It was never about volume. It was about the person speaking. When you don't love someone, the sound of their breath is an imposition.
...
The morning of the dress fitting arrived.
Even though I had no intention of marrying him, that gown had taken months of custom design. It was my vision, my sketches, my dream. It belonged to me, not him.
Shane pulled up to the curb outside my apartment.
I walked down, opened the passenger door, and stopped.
Kelsey was already sitting there, her designer shades perched on her head. She gave me an apologetic pout, but made no move to shift. "I’m so sorry, Willa. I get terribly carsick in the backseat."
Shane leaned across the console, his voice defensive. "She gets nauseous. Just sit in the back."
I closed the passenger door, stepped onto the sidewalk, and took out my phone to order an Uber.
Shane killed the engine, jumped out of the car, and grabbed my wrist. He shoved me forcefully toward the rear door. "We're going together. Stop causing a scene."
I stumbled, my head striking the metal edge of the doorframe with a sickening thud. Pain flared behind my eyes, blinding white.
Before I could even find my footing or close the door, he threw the car into drive and slammed on the gas.
The sudden acceleration flung me forward; my chest slammed against the back of the front seat with a hollow crack, then ricocheted back against the upholstery.
Shane slammed on the brakes, turning around to glare at me in fury. "Are you an idiot? You don't know how to put on a seatbelt? That crash scared Kelsey half to death!"
Kelsey patted her chest dramatically. "I'm okay, Shane. I'm sure she didn't mean to do it. It's her big day—let's not ruin the mood."
Shane scoffed, gripping the steering wheel so tight his knuckles went white. "She just loves playing the mute victim. Can't even manage an apology."
I pressed trembling fingers against my temple, feeling the knot of swelling already rising under my skin. I turned to look out the window.
The city streets I had known my entire life looked entirely foreign.
At the boutique, the bridal consultant hurried forward with a garment bag. "Mr. Lawson! The custom gown for Mrs. Lawson is ready."
The consultant’s gaze drifted between Kelsey and me. Seeing Kelsey standing inches from Shane's side, impeccably styled, the woman naturally beamed at her. "Mrs. Lawson, would you like to take a look?"
Kelsey flustered, waving her hands. "Oh, no, you misunderstand! I'm not—"
Shane didn't bother correcting the woman. He simply took the ivory silk gown from the consultant's hands and pushed it into Kelsey's arms.
"Try it on first, Kel." He threw a dismissive glance toward me, sitting stiffly on the velvet sofa. "Willa’s in no condition to try on anything right now anyway."
I asked the receptionist for an ice pack and pressed it against my throbbing temple.
I closed my eyes.
It was always like this. Kelsey always had to "try it first."
When Shane bought me a pair of limited-edition heels, Kelsey tried them on first—and took them home because they fit her better.
When Shane bought a new sports car, Kelsey insisted on taking the first drive—and kept the keys for three weeks.
When we went to the boardwalk pier and I wanted to ride the Ferris wheel at dusk, Kelsey begged to see the sunset from the top. Shane had unclipped my safety bar, told me to wait on the wooden planks below, and boarded the cabin with her.
When they came down twenty minutes later, their cheeks were flushed, and Kelsey's lipstick was smeared across her bottom lip.
If she wanted to try everything first, she could have him, too.
A heavy rustle of silk woke me from my daze. Shane tossed the wedding gown onto my lap.
"Kelsey tried it on. She says the silhouette is great. This is the one."
I looked down at the bodice. Kelsey was a size larger than me; the delicate boning along the ribs had already been warped and stretched. If I put it on, it would slip right off my chest.
The consultant cleared her throat awkwardly. "Mr. Lawson... I believe this gown might need significant alterations to fit this young lady’s frame."
Shane’s eyes turned cold. "You haven't even pinned her. How would you know?"
Before the woman could answer, Kelsey looped her arm through Shane's. "Shane, come look at the evening reception gowns with me! There's an emerald one that looks divine."
I watched them walk toward the VIP fitting area. Anyone walking in would have assumed they were the ones getting married.
I stood up, dropped the ice pack into the bin, and looked at the consultant.
"Go ahead and fit the reception dress on Mrs. Lawson," I said calmly.
Then I walked out.
...
That evening, I was in the foyer of our apartment, zipping up my second suitcase, when the front door swung open.
Shane froze, his gaze dropping to the luggage. He slammed the heavy front door behind him. "Where do you think you're going?"
I reached for the handle, intending to step around him.
He lunged forward, grabbing the telescoping handle of my bag and pinning it to the floor. "Cat got your tongue again?"
He ran a hand through his hair, exasperated. "You vanished from the bridal salon without saying a damn word. Because you walked out, none of the reception attire got finalized! You wasted my entire afternoon!"
I yanked the handle back from his grip and met his furious stare.
"As long as Mrs. Lawson likes them, they're finalized."
A flash of startled guilt crossed his face. He hadn't expected me to bite back. "Is that what this is? You're still throwing a jealous fit?"
He stepped closer, softening his tone into that familiar, patronizing cadence. "Look, you hurt your head today and you were out of it. Kelsey was just trying to help you out so you didn't have to stand on your feet."
A bitter laugh escaped my throat.
Whenever Kelsey was around, I was invisible. Whenever strangers mistook them for a couple, he never corrected them. And his apology was always the same: "You're being paranoid. She was just helping you. You should be grateful."
"So you did notice my head was bleeding," I whispered.
Shane glanced briefly at the bruised swelling near my hairline, then waved it off. "It's just a bump. Stop being so dramatic."
"Why did I ever expect anything from him?"
I turned back to the door, my fingers wrapping around the knob. Just as the latch clicked, my phone shrieked in my coat pocket.
I answered it. My uncle’s voice came through the receiver, ragged and gasping.
"Willa... it's your dad. Terrible accident on Route 9. Get to St. Mark's Hospital now."
The hallway seemed to drop into absolute, terrifying silence, replaced by a deafening ringing in my ears. The world tilted sideways. Tears broke over my lashes before I could draw another breath.
I shoved Shane aside, throwing the door open. My voice cracked into a desperate sob. "I'm coming. I'm coming right now."
Shane caught up with me in the garage, pulling his car up to the curb. "Get in!"
At the hospital, my legs were trembling so violently I could barely make it down the surgical corridor. The red "IN SURGERY" sign glared over the double doors.
I grabbed my uncle’s coat sleeve, shaking him. "What happened? How could this happen?!"
My uncle didn't answer. He just looked toward the plastic chairs against the wall.
Sitting there, hunched over and shivering, was Kelsey.
Seeing me, she buried her face in her hands and began to wail loudly. "I didn't mean to! I swear I didn't mean to!"
"The light was turning yellow—there was only a second left, and I didn't want to wait for the next cycle, so I stepped on the gas..." Her voice hitched into high-pitched hysterics. "How was I supposed to know your dad’s truck would pull out?!"
Something snapped inside my skull.
I lunged forward, grabbed two fistfuls of her hair, and whipped her head back, slamming my palm across her face.
"You're crying?!" I screamed, the sound tearing raw from my throat. "You blew an intersection! Why the hell are you sitting here while my father is dying behind those doors?!"
"Willa, stop!"
A heavy set of hands seized my shoulders and violently threw me backward.
My spine struck the concrete wall with a sickening crack. The breath punched out of my lungs, cold sweat beading instantly across my forehead as agony radiated down my back.
Shane stood between us, shielding Kelsey entirely with his body, his eyes glaring at me as if I were a feral animal.
"She already told you it was an accident! What more do you want from her?!"
Above us, the red surgical light flicked off.
The double doors swung open. The trauma surgeon stepped out, removing his surgical mask, his eyes dark with defeat.
He didn't need to speak. He just slowly shook his head. "We did everything we could. I'm so sorry. You should begin making arrangements."
The floor gave out beneath my feet. Blackness rushed in to swallow me whole.
...
When I opened my eyes, the harsh, clinical smell of rubbing alcohol stung my nostrils.
Shane was slumped in an armchair beside the hospital bed, dozing.
I pulled back the thin blanket and swung my feet over the edge. The mattress creaked softly, but it was enough to wake him.
He sat up, rubbing his eyes. His first words weren't to ask how I felt.
"Kelsey feels terrible about this, Willa. Don't go making this personal."
I froze by the bedside, my vocal cords raw and dry as sand. "She killed my father."
He stood up, reaching for my hand. "It was an accident."
I pulled my hand back as if he were covered in venom. "I'll handle it myself."
The next afternoon, at the memorial chapel.
I knelt on the cold stone floor, grief wrenching from the deepest caverns of my chest—a sound so hollow and suffocating that several family members turned away, unable to bear it. Tears soaked the black linen of my dress, dark stains spreading across my knees.
Shane stood a few feet away, hands tucked casually into his trouser pockets, looking down at me.
"Could you keep it down?" he murmured, leaning over. "He's already gone, Willa. Wailing like this won't bring him back."
He sighed, rolling his shoulders. "Honestly, it’s giving me an earache."
Checking his watch, he turned on his heel. "Don't forget the rehearsal and the ceremony tomorrow. Be there."
The next morning, I arrived at the venue.
When Shane saw me standing in the bridal suite wearing the ivory gown, a visible wave of relief washed over his face.
"I knew you'd come around," he murmured, smoothing his lapels. "The guests are seated. Let's get this over with."
Down the hall, Kelsey emerged from the dressing area. She was draped in a sweeping emerald silk gown—the very dress I had spent weeks customizing for my evening reception. She spun on her heels in front of Shane.
"Shane, does this look pretty on me?"
Shane’s mouth curved into a warm, genuine smile. "Stunning. You look amazing in everything."
I watched them, numb to the bone.
That dress had been tailored to my measurements, meant for my toasts, meant for my wedding night. Now, it had been handed to the bridesmaid. To any stranger walking in, she looked like the bride.
"That's my reception dress," I said, my voice empty. "If she's wearing it, what am I supposed to wear?"
Shane smiled smoothly, entirely prepared. He reached behind a rack and pulled out an off-the-rack, mud-brown tulle dress with stiff, unflattering ruffles.
"Kelsey was thoughtful enough to pick this out for you," he said.
Kelsey glided over, attempting to loop her arm through mine. "I spent hours looking for this, Willa. Don't let my hard work go to waste, okay?"
I pulled my arm back, letting her hands fall into empty air.
Kelsey’s pout stiffened. Shane’s expression darkened instantly. "What is your problem now? That’s the only backup dress we have. Wear it or don't."
A dead heart doesn't bleed.
He had promised me an unforgettable wedding. He had promised to make me the most cherished bride in the city, to make everyone envy what we had.
Instead, he dressed his white moonlight in my gowns, while I had no say in a single stitch of fabric.
A catering server rushed past, balancing a tray of champagne flutes. His elbow bumped Kelsey’s shoulder, sloshing dark red wine down the front of the emerald silk.
"Shane!" Kelsey shrieked, clutching the stained fabric. "My dress is ruined! It feels disgusting!"
After berating the terrified server, Shane grabbed a napkin, frantically dabbing at her skirt. Then he stopped, his gaze snapping directly to me.
"Willa. Swap with her."
"This is my wedding dress," I said flatly.
He scoffed, utterly indifferent. "Everyone knows you're the bride. What difference does the dress make? Besides, weren't you just whining about wanting the reception dress? I'm granting your wish. Now you won't have an excuse to be jealous."
I looked at him, then at the ruined emerald dress.
"Fine," I said. "I'll swap."
It made my next move infinitely easier.
A flicker of unease crossed Shane's face—perhaps shocked by how easily I had yielded—but it vanished as quickly as it came.
Twenty minutes later, the organ roared to life.
Shane stood at the end of the aisle in his sharp black tuxedo.
I walked toward him, the whispers of the crowd rustling like dry leaves on either side of the carpet.
"Why isn't the bride wearing white?"
"Look at the bridesmaid in the wedding gown... is that a mix-up?"
"There's a wine stain right down the front of the bride's skirt..."
I reached the altar and stood across from him.
Shane took a breath, smiling as he slid the platinum band toward my finger.
I let my hand tilt subtly downward. The ring slipped off his fingertips, hitting the wooden riser with a soft "tink", rolling away beneath the floral arrangements.
The smug confidence on his face cracked.
The officiant swallowed hard, trying to salvage the ceremony. "Let us proceed with the vows. Do you, Shane Lawson, take Willa Davis to be your lawfully wedded wife?"
Shane didn't hesitate. "I do."
The officiant turned to me. "And do you, Willa Davis, take—"
I stayed completely silent.
A murmur rippled through the pews, growing louder by the second.
Shane leaned in, his voice a furious hiss through his clenched teeth. "Say 'I do.' Willa, stop making a scene! Not here!"
I looked at him and smiled—a slow, terrifyingly serene smile.
Right on cue, the heavy mahogany double doors at the back of the chapel slammed open.
Two uniformed police officers stepped into the room, their boots echoing against the marble.
"Is there a Kelsey Bowen here?"